--- phase: 13-llm plan: 06 subsystem: semantic-segmentation tags: [strategy-pattern, protocol, unified-segmentation, extensibility, llm] # Dependency graph requires: - phase: 13-01 provides: video-type-detection - phase: 13-02 provides: semantic-boundary-detection - phase: 13-03 provides: content-completeness-protection - phase: 13-04 provides: title-generation - phase: 13-05 provides: chinese-sentence-boundary provides: - SegmentationStrategy Protocol interface for extensibility - UnifiedSegmentationStrategy implementing unified approach (all video types) - SemanticSegmentationEngine using strategy injection pattern - Comprehensive test suite for strategy architecture affects: [13-07-srt-processor-integration] # Tech tracking tech-stack: added: [] patterns: [strategy-pattern, protocol-interface, dependency-injection, lazy-initialization] key-files: created: [] modified: - kb_workflow/srt/semantic_engine.py (554 lines) - tests/test_semantic_engine.py (992 lines) key-decisions: - "Strategy Pattern with Protocol interface for extensibility (STRAT-01)" - "Unified segmentation strategy for all video types (per user decision, STRAT-02)" - "Strategy injection via constructor for easy testing and extension (STRAT-03)" patterns-established: - "Strategy Pattern: SegmentationStrategy Protocol defines interface" - "Unified Strategy: Single strategy for all video types (Phase 13)" - "Dependency Injection: SemanticSegmentationEngine accepts strategy via __init__" - "Lazy Initialization: AI client and fallback segmenter initialized on demand" requirements-completed: [STRAT-01, STRAT-02, STRAT-03] # Metrics duration: 12min started: 2026-03-21T16:28:24Z completed: 2026-03-21T16:40:15Z tasks: 1 files: 2 --- # Phase 13 Plan 06: Extensible Strategy Architecture Summary **Strategy Pattern with SegmentationStrategy Protocol interface and UnifiedSegmentationStrategy for all video types** ## Performance - **Duration:** 12 min - **Started:** 2026-03-21T16:28:24Z - **Completed:** 2026-03-21T16:40:15Z - **Tasks:** 1 - **Files modified:** 2 ## Accomplishments - Implemented SegmentationStrategy Protocol interface defining the strategy contract - Implemented UnifiedSegmentationStrategy with unified approach for all video types (per user decision) - Refactored SemanticSegmentationEngine to use strategy injection pattern - Added comprehensive test suite (10 tests) verifying strategy extensibility - Preserved all existing functionality (video type detection, prompt building, fallback mechanism) ## Task Commits Each task was committed atomically: 1. **Task 1: Implement extensible strategy architecture** - `0d8ed1f` (feat) **Plan metadata:** (pending final commit) ## Files Created/Modified - `kb_workflow/srt/semantic_engine.py` - Added SegmentationStrategy Protocol, UnifiedSegmentationStrategy class, refactored SemanticSegmentationEngine to use strategy pattern (554 lines) - `tests/test_semantic_engine.py` - Added TestStrategyPatternArchitecture (7 tests) and TestStrategyPatternIntegration (3 tests) for comprehensive strategy verification (992 lines) ## Deviations from Plan None - plan executed exactly as specified. ### Implementation Details **SegmentationStrategy Protocol:** - Defines the `segment()` method signature for all strategies - Uses Python's `typing.Protocol` for structural subtyping - Enables runtime duck typing with compile-time type checking **UnifiedSegmentationStrategy:** - Implements unified approach for all video types (per user decision) - Video type used only for prompt context, not for strategy selection - Contains all LLM interaction logic moved from SemanticSegmentationEngine - Preserves video type detection, prompt building, and fallback mechanisms **SemanticSegmentationEngine:** - Now uses strategy injection via constructor - Defaults to UnifiedSegmentationStrategy when no strategy provided - Delegates all segmentation logic to the strategy - Simplified to a thin wrapper around the strategy **Test Coverage:** - TestStrategyPatternArchitecture (7 tests): - Protocol interface definition - UnifiedSegmentationStrategy implementation - SemanticSegmentationEngine uses strategy - Custom strategy injection - Unified strategy applies to all video types - Strategy switching doesn't affect functionality - Strategy extensibility for future types - TestStrategyPatternIntegration (3 tests): - Preserves video type detection - Preserves prompt building - Preserves fallback mechanism ## Decisions Made **Architecture Decision: Strategy Pattern with Protocol Interface** - Rationale: Enables future extension without modifying existing code (Open/Closed Principle) - Protocol provides clear contract while allowing duck typing - Easy to add new strategies (e.g., KnowledgeTypeStrategy, StoryTypeStrategy) in future **Design Decision: Unified Strategy for Phase 13** - Per user decision: No type-specific strategies in Phase 13 - Video type used only for prompt context, not strategy selection - Architecture ready for type-specific strategies if needed later **Implementation Decision: Strategy Injection via Constructor** - Allows easy testing with mock strategies - Supports runtime strategy switching if needed - Follows dependency injection best practices ## Requirements Completed - **STRAT-01:** SegmentationStrategy Protocol interface defined ✅ - **STRAT-02:** UnifiedSegmentationStrategy implemented for all video types ✅ - **STRAT-03:** Strategy architecture supports extensibility (verified via custom strategy injection test) ✅ ## Next Phase Readiness **Ready for Phase 13 Plan 07 (SRTProcessor Integration):** - Strategy architecture complete and tested - SemanticSegmentationEngine provides clean interface - All existing functionality preserved - No blockers or concerns **Architecture Benefits:** - Easy to add new strategies without modifying existing code - Testable design with dependency injection - Clear separation of concerns (engine vs strategy) - Ready for future enhancements (type-specific strategies, advanced heuristics) --- *Phase: 13-llm* *Plan: 06* *Completed: 2026-03-21*