kb-skills/gsd-openclaw/.planning/phases/04-gsd-integration/04-VERIFICATION.md

phase, verified, status, score

phase	verified	status	score
04-gsd-integration	2026-03-11T19:30:00Z	passed	11/11 must-haves verified

Phase 4: GSD Integration Verification Report

Phase Goal: Bridge GSD commands from Feishu to tmux sessions - All GSD slash commands are fully bridged with complete workflow support Verified: 2026-03-11T19:30:00Z Status: passed Re-verification: No - initial verification

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	User's project context persists across chat sessions	VERIFIED	UserContextManager with atomic writes to ~/gsd-workspaces/.users/{user_id}/context.json (lines 143-183 in user_context.py)
2	User context is stored in isolated per-user files	VERIFIED	context_path property returns users_root / user_id / "context.json" (line 102 in user_context.py)
3	User context writes are atomic and crash-safe	VERIFIED	tempfile.mkstemp + os.replace pattern (lines 173, 178 in user_context.py)
4	Each user has independent project tracking	VERIFIED	TestMultiUser tests verify isolation (tests/test_user_context.py lines 262-307)
5	User can send /gsd:new-project through chat and get a pre-created session	VERIFIED	_handle_new_project creates session before executing command (orchestrator.py lines 97-154)
6	User can send /gsd:use to switch their current project context	VERIFIED	_handle_use_project updates user context (orchestrator.py lines 156-208)
7	User receives clear error when /gsd:use references non-existent project	VERIFIED	Returns error card with "Create New Project" button (orchestrator.py lines 191-202)
8	Generic GSD commands pass through correctly	VERIFIED	handle_message routes to session execution for non-special commands (orchestrator.py lines 269-317)
9	Long commands (execute-phase, plan-phase, discuss-phase, new-project) don't timeout	VERIFIED	LONG_COMMANDS set in both CommandExecutor and Orchestrator with adaptive timeout=None
10	Regular commands still use 60 second default timeout	VERIFIED	timeout = None if self._is_long_command(command) else self.executor.DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (line 288)
11	Create New Project button callback works from error card	VERIFIED	handle_callback routes action="new-project" to _handle_new_project (orchestrator.py lines 345-355)

Score: 11/11 truths verified

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Expected	Status	Details
src/gsd_openclaw/user_context.py	UserContextManager class	VERIFIED	250 lines, UserContext dataclass + UserContextManager with load/save/atomic writes
tests/test_user_context.py	Tests for UserContextManager	VERIFIED	20 tests across 4 test classes (TestUserContext, TestUserContextManager, TestAtomicWrites, TestMultiUser)
src/gsd_openclaw/orchestrator.py	Extended Orchestrator	VERIFIED	_handle_new_project, _handle_use_project, LONG_COMMANDS, adaptive timeout, callback handling
tests/test_orchestrator.py	Tests for special commands	VERIFIED	TestSpecialCommands (13 tests), TestAdaptiveTimeout (6 tests), TestHandleCallback (7 tests)
src/gsd_openclaw/command_executor.py	Long command support	VERIFIED	LONG_COMMANDS set, _is_long_command method
tests/test_command_executor.py	Tests for long commands	VERIFIED	TestLongCommands class (5 tests)
src/gsd_openclaw/__init__.py	Exports UserContext, UserContextManager	VERIFIED	Lines 17, 37-38

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
orchestrator.py	user_context.py	UserContextManager	WIRED	Line 23 import, Line 70 dict, Lines 73-84 _get_user_context_manager
orchestrator.py	tmux_session.py	create_session for new-project	WIRED	Line 18 import, Line 121 create_session call
orchestrator.py	response_formatter.py	CardButton for error cards	WIRED	Line 22 import, Lines 193-197 CardButton instantiation
command_executor.py	LONG_COMMANDS	_is_long_command detection	WIRED	Lines 156, 202-219
orchestrator.py	command_executor.py	execute() with adaptive timeout	WIRED	Line 288 timeout calculation, Line 291 executor.execute call
user_context.py	filesystem	tempfile.mkstemp + os.replace	WIRED	Lines 173, 178 atomic write pattern

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Source Plan	Description	Status	Evidence
BRDG-06	04-01, 04-02, 04-03	All GSD slash commands are supported	SATISFIED	UserContextManager for context tracking, /gsd:new-project pre-creates session, /gsd:use switches context, generic commands pass through, long commands have no timeout, button callbacks work

Anti-Patterns Found

File	Line	Pattern	Severity	Impact
None	-	-	-	No blocker or warning patterns found

Anti-pattern scan results:

• No TODO/FIXME/HACK/PLACEHOLDER comments in production code
• No empty implementations (return null, return {})
• The return [] in user_context.py line 233 is correct behavior for new users with no recent projects
• All handler methods have substantive implementations

Human Verification Required

The following items need human testing to verify full workflow:

1. End-to-end /gsd:new-project flow

   • Test: Send /gsd:new-project test-project via Feishu chat
   • Expected: Project created, tmux session started, user context updated
   • Why human: Requires live Feishu integration and tmux environment

2. End-to-end /gsd:use flow with error recovery

   • Test: Send /gsd:use nonexistent-project, then click "Create New Project" button
   • Expected: Error card with button appears, clicking button creates project
   • Why human: Requires live Feishu card button callback handling

3. Long command timeout behavior

   • Test: Execute /gsd:execute-phase on a multi-phase project
   • Expected: Command runs without 60-second timeout
   • Why human: Requires real GSD CLI and long-running operation

4. Multi-user context isolation

   • Test: Two users send commands simultaneously from different Feishu accounts
   • Expected: Each user's context is independent, no cross-contamination
   • Why human: Requires multiple live Feishu sessions

Test Results

All 90 automated tests pass:

tests/test_user_context.py: 20 tests PASSED
tests/test_orchestrator.py: 55 tests PASSED
tests/test_command_executor.py: 15 tests PASSED

Key test classes:

• TestUserContext (3 tests) - UserContext dataclass
• TestUserContextManager (4 tests) - Manager initialization and loading
• TestAtomicWrites (6 tests) - Crash-safe persistence
• TestMultiUser (7 tests) - User isolation
• TestSpecialCommands (13 tests) - /gsd:new-project and /gsd:use handling
• TestAdaptiveTimeout (6 tests) - Long command timeout logic
• TestHandleCallback (7 tests) - Button callback routing
• TestLongCommands (5 tests) - CommandExecutor long command detection

Gaps Summary

No gaps found. All must-haves verified:

• UserContextManager provides persistent per-user context with atomic writes
• /gsd:new-project pre-creates session and updates context
• /gsd:use switches context, shows error with "Create New Project" button
• Generic commands use user context for project selection
• Long commands execute without timeout
• Button callbacks work for new-project action
• All 90 tests pass

---

Verified: 2026-03-11T19:30:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)