--- phase: 03-orchestration plan: 02 subsystem: orchestration tags: [approval, progress, callbacks, feishu-cards, throttling] # Dependency graph requires: - phase: 02-integration-layer provides: FeishuResponseFormatter, CardButton for card creation - phase: 01-core-infrastructure provides: StateManager for persistence provides: - ApprovalHandler class for approval workflow state management - ApprovalState dataclass for approval data - ProgressMonitor class for progress detection and update logic - ProgressInfo dataclass for progress data affects: [03-03, 04-full-command-support] # Tech tracking tech-stack: added: [] patterns: - Pattern matching for approval request detection - Content-hash based progress pattern extraction - Time-based throttling for progress updates - In-memory approval cache with UUID-based IDs key-files: created: - src/gsd_openclaw/approval_handler.py - src/gsd_openclaw/progress_monitor.py - tests/test_approval_handler.py - tests/test_progress_monitor.py modified: - src/gsd_openclaw/__init__.py key-decisions: - "No timeout limit for approvals - wait for user response or session end" - "60 second default interval for progress updates (from CONTEXT.md)" - "Fraction pattern allows content after fraction (e.g., [3/5 tasks])" patterns-established: - "ApprovalState dataclass with approval_id, session_id, project_name, context, created_at" - "ProgressInfo dataclass with type, value, current, total fields" - "CardButton with value dict containing action, approval_id, project for callbacks" requirements-completed: [BRDG-04, BRDG-05] # Metrics duration: 5min completed: 2026-03-11 --- # Phase 3 Plan 2: Approval Handler and Progress Monitor Summary **Approval workflow with confirm/reject card buttons and progress monitoring with 60-second throttled updates** ## Performance - **Duration:** 5 min - **Started:** 2026-03-11T07:57:20Z - **Completed:** 2026-03-11T08:05:00Z - **Tasks:** 3 - **Files modified:** 4 ## Accomplishments - Implemented ApprovalHandler with approval pattern detection (AskUserQuestion, ExitPlanMode, 需要确认, Please confirm) - Implemented approval card creation with confirm/reject buttons using CardButton - Implemented callback handling for approve/reject actions - Implemented ProgressMonitor with progress extraction (percentage, fraction, phase, completion) - Implemented 60-second throttled progress updates - Created comprehensive test suite with 15 tests (326 lines total) ## Task Commits Each task was committed atomically: 1. **Task 1: Create test scaffolds** - `99f7536` (test) 2. **Task 2: Implement ApprovalHandler class** - `af43b28` (feat) 3. **Task 3: Implement ProgressMonitor class** - `a8631dc` (feat) **Plan metadata:** `8ed8823` (feat: export classes from package) ## Files Created/Modified - `src/gsd_openclaw/approval_handler.py` - Approval workflow state management with ApprovalState and ApprovalHandler - `src/gsd_openclaw/progress_monitor.py` - Progress detection and update logic with ProgressInfo and ProgressMonitor - `tests/test_approval_handler.py` - 8 tests for approval handling - `tests/test_progress_monitor.py` - 7 tests for progress monitoring - `src/gsd_openclaw/__init__.py` - Added exports for new classes ## Decisions Made - Used UUID for approval IDs to ensure uniqueness across sessions - Approval buttons use primary (confirm) and danger (reject) button types - No timeout for approvals - wait indefinitely for user response - Progress patterns checked in order: percentage, fraction, phase, completion - should_send_update returns False on first call (no previous update) ## Deviations from Plan ### Auto-fixed Issues **1. [Rule 1 - Bug] Fixed test assertions to use kwargs** - **Found during:** Task 2 (ApprovalHandler tests) - **Issue:** Tests accessed positional args (call_args[0][0]) but implementation uses keyword args - **Fix:** Changed to call_args.kwargs.get("title") pattern - **Files modified:** tests/test_approval_handler.py, tests/test_progress_monitor.py - **Verification:** All 15 tests pass - **Committed in:** af43b28, a8631dc (Task 2 and 3 commits) **2. [Rule 1 - Bug] Fixed fraction pattern to allow content after fraction** - **Found during:** Task 3 (ProgressMonitor tests) - **Issue:** Pattern `\[(\d+)/(\d+)\]` didn't match `[3/5 tasks]` with extra content - **Fix:** Changed to `\[(\d+)/(\d+)(?:[^\]]*)\]` to allow optional content - **Files modified:** src/gsd_openclaw/progress_monitor.py - **Verification:** Test test_extract_progress_returns_fraction passes - **Committed in:** a8631dc (Task 3 commit) **3. [Rule 1 - Bug] Fixed should_send_update to return False on first call** - **Found during:** Task 3 (ProgressMonitor tests) - **Issue:** should_send_update returned True when last_update_time=0 because elapsed time was huge - **Fix:** Added check for last_update_time == 0.0 to return False on first call - **Files modified:** src/gsd_openclaw/progress_monitor.py - **Verification:** Test test_should_send_update_returns_false_immediately passes - **Committed in:** a8631dc (Task 3 commit) --- **Total deviations:** 3 auto-fixed (all Rule 1 - Bug fixes) **Impact on plan:** All auto-fixes necessary for correctness. No scope creep. ## Issues Encountered - pytest not installed in venv - reinstalled with `pip install pytest libtmux pyyaml` ## User Setup Required None - no external service configuration required. ## Next Phase Readiness - Approval and progress modules complete, ready for orchestrator integration - ApprovalHandler and ProgressMonitor can be used by Phase 3 Plan 3 for command routing - All 143 tests pass across the project --- *Phase: 03-orchestration* *Completed: 2026-03-11*